At today’s police briefing, we’ll hear about Howard Paul Allen.
Police Chief Doug Barthel and Minnehaha County State’s Attorney Aaron McGowan will be in attendance, we’re told.
Chances are they’ve made an arrest in what has been the city’s only unsolved homicide since 1999. That year, 27-year-old Pamela Halverson’s body was found in the back of a Ford Tempo a few blocks from her home.
I’d assumed that Allen’s 2010 case was closed.
The Montana native was 52 years old when he was found stabbed to death inside his apartment on the 2400 block of South Marion Road in late 2010.
It was the 11th homicide of the year, which was the most murderous in modern Sioux Falls history. Allen’s was one of seven that qualified as homicide for statistical purposes, three others were vehicular homicides and one was ruled justifiable homicide.
We never did learn much about Allen or the circumstances surrounding his death. We knew he was stabbed. We knew it happened early in the morning. We knew the cops thought the killer was someone Allen knew.
The next morning, I remember standing on the sidewalk near the house and talking to a city employee. The guy was holding a big hose that ran from the pool in Allen’s backyard to the street out front. He was watching the water spurt out intently. He told me his orders were to watch for something. I could only assume that “something” was a knife, perhaps tossed in the water by Allen’s killer, but the guy wouldn’t say that.
Allen’s landlord – his upstairs neighbor – didn’t want to talk to the media. He shooed us all away and chewed out the TV cameramen and women for standing too close to his house. The neighbors nearby didn’t know anything about Allen. One elderly woman wondered aloud if Allen was the quiet fellow she sometimes saw walking from to the Hy-Vee just down the road at 26th Street and Marion.
What I was able to learn about Allen was that he had an alcohol problem. Our Argus archive showed that he’d been convicted of at least five DUIs since moving to Sioux Falls from Montana about 10 years ago.
He also had an ongoing dispute with a guy named Eric Richard Brim, against whom Allen once took out a protection order. Brim slashed Allen’s tires in 2006, the order said. Brim was later charged with stalking Allen. Allen was charged with domestic violence against Mr. Brim in 2006 and 2007. Both cases were dismissed.
None of that was particularly relevant to the story, and I never wrote it into a story. I didn’t have any proof that Allen and Brim had been in contact for quite a while. If I hear Brim’s name today, I’ll probably fall out of my chair.
Before learning about the Allen-Brim disputes, I wrote Allen’s fifth-offense DUI into a story about his death.
This upset a family member of Mr. Allen’s quite a bit. She called and chewed me out for including “the one thing you could find” about Allen and throwing it out for the public.
I told her that in murder stories, almost every detail about the victim ends up in the media eventually. There was no malice attached to the inclusion of the DUIs, I told her. I also said that once the killer was found, more embarrassing details could emerge. One of 2010’s murder victims was a meth dealer. Another one was beaten to death by the boyfriend of a young woman he was coming on to at a party – and by “coming on to,” I mean walking towards her with his pants and underwear off.
By the end of the conversation with Allen’s Montana kin, the woman told me she was glad to have spoken to me. She said she would rather know and accept that an onslaught of ugly details was forthcoming than to be upset every time she saw a new one.
And then nothing happened. Even with dirty details (let’s be honest, there might not be many or any), my guess is she’d want to see Allen’s killer brought to justice.
In any event, we’re about to know a lot more about the case by mid-morning.


